Skip to content
Elections & Politics Blackford County

Smith wins commissioner seat, Armstrong unseats Jones in Blackford County election

By Derek Wheeler The Blackford Ledger
Smith wins commissioner seat, Armstrong unseats Jones in Blackford County election
Image might be generated by AI and not necessarily reflective of the actual subject of the article.

Republican Shane Smith won the District 2 seat on the Blackford County Board of Commissioners on Tuesday. He beat independent Dennis Layman 1,629 votes to 1,179, according to the county’s unofficial Election Summary Report.

Smith took 58.01% of the vote. Layman took 41.99%.

All 12 precincts reported. The results remain unofficial until the county election board certifies them.

School board

Kerra Armstrong defeated school board president Phil Jones in District 3. Armstrong, listed on the ballot as a Republican, received 1,676 votes (62.21%). Jones received 1,018 (37.79%).

District 1 was the closest race on the county ballot. Kyle J. Pitts, listed as a Republican, beat independent Melinda Huber by 89 votes. Pitts received 1,461 votes (51.57%). Huber received 1,372 (48.43%).

Scott Malott ran unopposed in District 2 and received 2,049 votes.

County council

Republicans won all four county council seats on the ballot.

  • District 1: Jeff Whetzel (R) defeated Ashlee Beeman (D), 483 to 273 (63.89% to 36.11%).

  • District 2: Heather Scaggs (R) ran unopposed and received 447 votes.

  • District 3: Deb Grider (R) defeated John Velasquez (D), 580 to 277 (67.68% to 32.32%).

  • District 4: Kyle Lechien (R) ran unopposed and received 718 votes.

Turnout

Voters cast 3,189 ballots. The county has 7,978 registered voters, for a turnout of 39.97%.

More than half of all ballots were cast before Election Day. Walk-in absentee voters cast 1,560 ballots. Paper absentee voters cast 83. Election Day voters cast 1,546.

Straight-party voting accounted for 957 ballots. Of those, 752 were straight Republican and 205 were straight Democratic.

Uncontested county offices

Six Republicans ran without opponents:

  • Prosecuting Attorney, 71st Judicial Circuit: Aaron M. Henderson, 2,365 votes

  • Auditor: Lisa Flint Simmons, 2,352

  • Sheriff: Jim Heflin, 2,353

  • Coroner: Adam Solga, 2,356

  • Surveyor: Chris Green, 2,334

  • Assessor: Sheila Hyer, 2,309

Township races

Four township trustees ran unopposed: Kimberly Twibell in Harrison (498 votes), Jennifer Kaufman in Jackson (265), Stephen Hurd in Licking (1,362) and Courtney Lechien in Washington (238). All four are Republicans.

Harrison Township had three candidates for three board seats. Debra Penrod (R) received 331 votes, Joel Neff (R) 312 and Lucrethia Altman (D) 177.

Licking Township had two candidates for three board seats. Amy S. Lathem (R) received 939 votes. Gloria J. Mahan (D) received 757.

No candidates filed for the Jackson Township or Washington Township boards. Each board had three seats on the ballot.

Jay County School Board

A small number of Blackford County voters cast ballots in Jay County School Board races. These totals cover only Blackford County voters. Final outcomes depend on ballots cast in Jay County.

In District 2, Blackford County voters split evenly. Tom E. Crouch, listed as a Republican, and Desiree (Desi) Brown each received 11 votes.

In District 3, Donna Geesaman received 12 votes. Kendra McLaughlin, listed as a Republican, received 8.

Ronald J. Laux, listed as a Republican, ran unopposed in District 5 and received 17 votes.

State and federal races

The totals below reflect Blackford County voters only. Final outcomes depend on results from other counties.

Race

Candidate

Votes

%

U.S. House, District 3

Marlin A. Stutzman (R)

2,005

66.46%

Kelly Thompson (D)

1,008

33.41%

Write-in

4

0.13%

State Senate, District 19

Blake Fiechter (R)

2,037

67.41%

Timothy C. Murphy (D)

985

32.59%

State House, District 33

John (J.D.) Prescott (R)

1,957

64.93%

John E. Bartlett (D)

1,057

35.07%

Secretary of State

Max Engling (R)

1,744

56.72%

Beau Bayh (D)

1,103

35.87%

Greg Ballard (LIN)

126

4.10%

Lauri A. Shillings (L)

102

3.32%

State Comptroller

Elise Nieshalla (R)

1,913

63.34%

Jessica Bailey (D)

922

30.53%

John Schick (L)

185

6.13%

Treasurer of State

Daniel Elliott (R)

2,083

69.55%

Coumba Kebe (D)

912

30.45%

Public questions

Blackford County voters approved both statewide public questions.

  • Right to Bail: Yes 1,853 (67.63%), No 887 (32.37%)

  • Judge Residence: Yes 1,907 (64.58%), No 1,046 (35.42%)

Judicial retention

Blackford County voters favored retaining all four judges on the ballot.

  • Court of Appeals District 2, Kenworthy: Yes 69.59%

  • Court of Appeals District 4, DeBoer: Yes 68.79%

  • Court of Appeals District 5, Felix: Yes 67.99%

  • Indiana Tax Court, McAdam: Yes 67.87%

About our reporting: The Blackford Ledger builds its government coverage from official public records, and every report is reviewed by an editor before publication. Read our Editorial Policy & Corrections or request a correction.

TAGS: Blackford County election 2026 general election county commissioners school board election results