Cherry Street Club Filing Dismissed in Hartford City
From the Blackford County BZA meeting on November 17, 2026
Applicants seeking a private club at 221 North Cherry Street must start over after the Blackford County BZA dismissed their petition Nov. 17 without deciding whether to allow the use.
The dismissal was without prejudice, meaning the applicants may file a new request. Residents had raised objections at Hartford City's Nov. 2 council meeting before bringing their concerns to the county hearing.
Family members described plans for gatherings, weddings, fundraisers and other events in the former church building, which is in an R3 residential area. They said they had purchased lots across the street for parking. Operating details, including security and alcohol arrangements, were unsettled, and occupancy calculations were unfinished.
Residents raised concerns about traffic, parking and noise, along with safety and nearby preschools. Mayor Dan Eckstein and Council Member Dudelston asked the board to deny the request.
Board members said the proposal needed a fuller business plan and clearer treatment under zoning rules. They also called for better notice if the parking lots across the street were part of the application. A new filing would require fresh notices and a broader explanation of the proposed use.
Source: YouTube transcript — Blackford County - Board of Zoning & Appeals BZA - November 17, 2026 (at 34:00)
Some information may be inaccurate due to video audio quality.
About our reporting: The Blackford Ledger builds its government coverage from official public records, and every report is reviewed by an editor before publication. Read our Editorial Policy & Corrections or request a correction.